Selecting a Medical Specialist

Introduction

Everyone knows that a "Medical Doctor" is a physician who has had years of training to understand the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of disease. The basic training for a physician specialist includes four years of premedical education in a college or university, four years of medical school, and after receiving the M.D. degree, at least three years of specialty training under supervision (called a "residency"). Training in subspecialties can take an additional one to three years.

 

The process most widely used by physicians to tell whether and why you are sick is to ask you, and/or family members, questions about your health and past medical history. This process, "taking a history," is usually followed by an appropriate physical examination of your body to determine how well it is functioning and whether there are signs of disease. Doctors also use a variety of tests such as lab tests, x-rays, other imaging techniques, and additional procedures to evaluate your health and identify any diseases or other health problems which may be present. Some of these diagnostic procedures (e.g., cardiac catheterization, CT scans, biopsy of internal tissues) are very complicated. They require many years of training in order to use them safely and accurately.

 

After the diagnostic process is completed, the doctor will recommend treatment if it is needed. Treatment may involve medication, surgery (there are many types of surgical specialists), or other complex procedures.

 

Some specialists are primary care doctors, such as family physicians, general internists, and general pediatricians. Other specialists concentrate on certain body systems, specific age groups, or complex scientific techniques developed to diagnose or treat certain types of disorders. Specialties in medicine developed because of the rapidly expanding body of knowledge about health and illness and the constantly evolving new treatment techniques for disease.

 

A subspecialist is a physician who has completed training in a general medical specialty and then takes additional training in a more specific area of that specialty called a subspecialty. This training increases the depth of knowledge and expertise of the specialist in that particular field. For example, cardiology is a subspecialty of internal medicine and pediatrics, pediatric surgery is a subspecialty of surgery, and child and adolescent psychiatry is a subspecialty of psychiatry. The training of a subspecialist within a specialty requires an additional one or more years of full-time education.

Training of a Specialist

The training of a specialist begins after the doctor has received the M.D. degree from a medical school, in what is called a residency. Resident physicians dedicate themselves for three to seven years to full-time experience in hospital and/or ambulatory care settings, caring for patients under the supervision of experienced specialists. Educational conferences and research experience are often part of that training. In years past, the first year of post-medical school training was called an internship, but is now called residency.

 

Licensure, the legal privilege to practice medicine, is governed by state law and is not designed to recognize the knowledge and skills of a trained specialist. A physician is licensed to practice general medicine and surgery by a state board of medical examiners after passing a state or national licensure examination. Each state or territory has its own procedures to license physicians, and sets the general standards for all physicians in that state or territory.

Who Credentials a Specialist and/or Subspecialist?

Specialty boards certify physicians as having met certain published standards. There are 24 specialty boards that are recognized by the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) and the American Medical Association (AMA). Remember, a subspecialist first must be trained and certified as a specialist.

In order to be certified as a medical specialist by one of these recognized boards, a physician must complete certain requirements. Generally, these include:

 

1.      Completion of a course of study leading to the M.D. or D.O. (Doctor of Osteopathy) degree from a recognized school of medicine.

2.      Completion of three to seven years of full-time training in an accredited residency program designed to train specialists in the field.

3.      Many specialty boards require assessments and documentation of individual performance from the residency training director, or from the chief of service in the hospital where the specialist has practiced.

4.      All of the ABMS Member Boards require that a person seeking certification have an unrestricted license to practice medicine in order to take the certification examination.

5.      Finally, each candidate for certification must pass a written examination given by the specialty board. Fifteen of the 24 specialty boards also require an oral examination conducted by senior specialists in that field. 

 

Candidates who have passed the exams and other requirements are then given the status of "Diplomate" and are certified as specialists. A similar process is followed for specialists who want to become subspecialists.

 

All of the ABMS Member Boards now, or will soon, issue only time-limited certificates which are valid for six to ten years. In order to retain certification, diplomates must become "recertified," and must periodically go through an additional process involving continuing education in the specialty, review of credentials and further examination. Boards that may not yet require recertification have provided voluntary recertification with similar requirements.

How to Determine if a Physician is a Certified Specialist

Certified specialists are listed in The Official ABMS Directory of Board Certified Medical Specialists published by Marquis Who ís Who. The ABMS Directory can be found in most public libraries, hospital libraries, university libraries and medical libraries, and is also available on CD-ROM. Alternatively, you could ask for that information from your county medical society, the American Board of Medical Specialties, or one of the specialty boards.

 

The ABMS also arranges for the publication of lists of certified specialists/subspecialists and operates a toll free phone line (1-866-ASK-ABMS) to verify the certification status of individual physicians. Additionally, information about the ABMS organization and links to an electronic directory of certified specialists can be accessed through the ABMS Web site at www.abms.org.

 

Almost all board certified specialists are also members of their medical specialty societies. These societies are dedicated to furthering standards, practice, and professional and public education within individual medical specialties. Some, such as the American College of Surgeons and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, require board certification for full membership. A physician who has attained full membership is called a "Fellow" of the society and is entitled to use this designation in all formal communications, such as certificates, publications, business cards, stationery and signage. Thus, "John Doe, M.D., F.A.C.S. (Fellow of the American College of Surgeons)" is a board certified surgeon. Similarly, F.A.A.D. (Fellow of the American Academy of Dermatology) following the M.D. or D.O. in a physician’s title would likely indicate board certification in that specialty.

The Purpose of Certification

The intent of the certification process, as defined by the member boards of the American Board of Medical Specialties, is to provide assurance to the public that a certified medical specialist has successfully completed an approved educational program and an evaluation, including an examination process designed to assess the knowledge, experience and skills requisite to the provision of high quality patient care in that specialty.

Glossary

Accreditation:

A process of review and approval of medical schools and graduate medical education training programs, residency programs, conducted by credentialing bodies and certifying that the programs have met certain standards. This process does not certify or accredit individuals.

The Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME), a joint committee of the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) and the American Medical Association (AMA) conducts accreditation of medical schools.

 

The Residency Review Committees (RRCs) of the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) are responsible for accrediting residency programs. There are 26 RRCs and their members come from relevant Member Boards of the ABMS, specialty societies and the AMA. The ACGME oversees the activities of the RRCs and approves or disapproves their recommendations.

 

Training:

Usually refers to a period of postgraduate medical education during which a physician gains the experience necessary to assume responsibility for the care of patients.

 

Internship:

The old term used to describe the first year of postgraduate training following graduation from medical school. Physicians participating in this training were formerly called interns but are now known as Postgraduate Year 1 (PGY-1) residents and the year is called the PGY-1 year. It is usually taken under the sponsorship of a single clinical department. See Transitional Year PGY-1.

 

Residency:

A variable period of postgraduate education and training (3- 7 years), based upon the specialty selected, in which a physician participates with the expectation of becoming a specialist of medical practice. These educational experiences occur in a variety of settings including hospitals, clinics, offices and other relevant medical educational centers.

 

Transitional Year Residency:

A training program for physicians equivalent to the PGY-1 residency training year, but organized and sponsored by several institutions or clinical departments to provide training in multiple specialties of medicine rather than in a single specialty.

 

Fellowship Training:

A period of training, usually 1-2 years, which occurs after completion of a general or primary residency. Its goal is to qualify a physician as a subspecialist in an area of medical practice such as cardiology, hand surgery, etc.

 

Residency Matching:

The process by which most medical students obtain an appointment for their postgraduate training. The matching process is performed by independent agencies such as the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP). The NRMP receives rank order preferences from students and training institutions and "matches" them by computer according to the highest ranked match. Residency information is available from medical schools, training programs, The AMA Directory of Graduate Medical Education Programs, hard copy and online, and the Fellowship and Residency Electronic Interactive Data Access (FREIDA) service of the AMA.

 

Licensure (Medical):

Legal permission granted by a state or territorial government to a physician to take personal, unsupervised responsibility for the diagnosis and treatment of patients in the practice of medicine. Most states and territories require that physicians complete at least 1 year, and several require 3 years, of graduate medical education to qualify for licensure. In addition, applicants for licensure must pass an examination. Qualifications for medical licensure in each jurisdiction are determined by that jurisdiction. Federal, state and territorial governments do not license physicians as specialists nor certify physicians as specialists.

 

Board Certification:

The process of voluntary testing and evaluation of physicians who wish to become board certified in a particular medical specialty. A physician may elect to begin the certification process only after completion of an approved residency training program.

 

Certification by a specialty board enables the public to identify those practitioners who have met a standard of training and experience set beyond the level required for licensure. Certifying boards, unlike state licensing boards, are national in scope and independent.

 

Specialty Boards:

There are 24 approved medical specialty boards that grant certification. These boards form the umbrella organization, the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS).

The specialty boards influence graduate medical education since they set the criteria required of physicians seeking admission to the certification examinations. Each board sets the minimum length of time for education in an accredited residency and the content of the certifying exam.

 

Candidate:

Individual who is qualified to take a specialty board certification.

 

Diplomate:

Individual who has met all specialty board requirements, including passing an examination, and is board certified in a particular medical specialty.

 

Specialty Societies:

Membership organizations of physicians involved in a given field of practice. Specialty societies represent the interests of practitioners. In most specialty societies it is necessary to be board certified to be eligible for membership.

 

Fellowship:

Physicians attain Fellowship status in a specialty society when they demonstrate outstanding achievement in their profession. Typical criteria for Fellowship in a specialty society include years of membership, years as a practitioner in the specialty and professional recognition by peers.